Can feelings have an rational basis philosophy essay
Are emotions irrational
It is difficult to arrive at new statements, it is cumbersome to find reasons and it is strenuous to verify an argument Arg. As an alternative, they propose an attitudinal theory of emotions. They provide an unambiguous way to express statements. If there is doubt about a statement, the statement can be discussed and clarified. Once new information that she has in fact won the election is acquired, a belief-belief-comparator system produces a belief disconfirmation signal subjectively experienced as surprise, and a belief-desire-comparator system produces a desire fulfillment signal subjectively experienced as pleasure. Fortunately, natural language has a built-in mechanisms to deal with unclear statements: In order to determine whether a message has been received, we can ask the receiver to paraphrase the message. This makes for a long and complicated history, which has progressively led to the development of a variety of shared insights about the nature and function of emotions, but no consensual definition of what emotions are, either in philosophy or in affective science. These questions raise complex conceptual issues we cannot address here see Moors , but they are essential for assessing the evidentiary support for appraisal theory. Describing the automatic appraisal mechanism, Ekman says: There must be an appraiser mechanism which selectively attends to those stimuli external or internal which are the occasion for activating the affect programme In this respect, emotions are held to be analogous to faculties such as vision or touch, which provide information about the relation between the subject and the world in various ways. For instance when we love a person we think they may be perfect and also have no flaws as to when you loathe them you see only their faults. Last, the apple might not actually be "green", but have red spots. Furthermore, different cultures might have different notions and granularities of "green". This concept is usually undisputed.
An unfalsifiable hypothesis is irrelevant, because it will make no difference if this hypothesis is true or false. There are two constituents of a primordial emotion--the specific sensation which when severe may be imperious, and the compelling intention for gratification by a consummatory act.
Rationality emphasizes the objectivity of an argument Arg. This is the idea that emotions are separate from the rational or cognitive operations of the mind: cognitive operations are cold and logical, whereas emotions are hot, irrational, and largely uncontrollable responses to certain events.
Have a look at the following non-rational statements: Love is everything. LeDoux  and Robert Zajonc  who are able to appeal to neurological evidence.
Given that individuals experience the emotions that they have terms for and vice versathe claim that follows from these findings is that people in different cultures have and experience different emotions.
Affect programs are explained further in section 4. Fortunately, rationality by itself does not require that much about the world be known. Simpson, D. Our emotions help us reason through things. In her "exclusively non-cognitive" theory, Robinson claims that any cognitive processes that occur in an emotion-causing situation are in addition to the core process, which is non-cognitive.
They provide an unambiguous way to express statements. This section covers some common concerns about rationality. Rationality, including this essay, relies on natural language.
based on 64 review